The 20-year-old beauty was seen dancing with the `The Hunger Games` star at a Golden Globe Awards afterparty at the Beverly Hilton Hotel on Sunday night, reported Hollywood Life.
"She was dancing and flirting with Josh," a source said.
Gomez seemed to have the approval of her good friend Vanessa Hudgens, who previously dated Hutcherson.
"(Vanessa) was there to witness it. Selena was dancing and having lots of fun and flirting with Josh. Vanessa needed to go to the bathroom and asked me where the restroom was, and I told them both (Vanessa and Selena) and they went. Josh followed them, and Selena and Josh left the Beverly Hilton together," the source said.